Sourdough Discard Eggnog Bread Pudding — Flavors, Inclusions & Pairings

Uneven scoop of sourdough eggnog bread pudding with dark golden bread tips and nutmeg dust on a chipped stoneware plate, crumbs on a scratched wooden board

The Flavor Profile

Crust & crumb: Golden, crisped bread tips on top give way to a soft, custard-soaked center. The cubes keep their edges, so every spoonful has both crunch and cream.

Flavor: Rich eggnog custard first, warm nutmeg and cinnamon through the middle, and a gentle sourdough tang underneath that keeps the sweetness from turning heavy.

Why it takes inclusions so well: The bread cubes are sponges by design. Anything folded in before the soak gets coated in spiced custard and bakes right into the pudding instead of sitting on top.

How Inclusions Fit This Recipe

The recipe uses 400 g of cubed day-old sourdough soaked in an eggnog and discard custard. Inclusions join at two clear moments:

  1. Cube and dry the bread first, exactly as the recipe directs.
  2. Whisk the custard until completely smooth.
  3. Scatter dry inclusions over the cubes in the dish before pouring.
  4. Pour the custard over everything and press gently so each piece is coated.
  5. Rest the full 30-minute soak so flavors settle into the bread.
  6. Bake until the center only jiggles slightly, then rest 15 minutes.

Keep total inclusions in the 10–30% range for this recipe — about 40–120 g against the 400 g of bread. Small, even pieces soak and bake most evenly.

One caution worth knowing: wet inclusions change the bake. Fresh fruit releases juice into the custard, so keep pieces small and stay at the lower end of the range, or the center will need extra minutes to set.

Dry inclusions behave the opposite way. Dried fruit and nuts drink up a little custard as the pudding sits, which is exactly why they go in before the soak rather than being sprinkled on at the table.

If you combine two inclusions, split the total between them instead of doubling it. Cranberry plus pecan at half weight each gives you contrast in every bite without crowding out the custard.

The Best Inclusions for This Pudding

Dried Cranberries

Use 20% — about 80 g. Scatter them over the cubes before the custard goes on. Their tart pop is the brightest contrast to the rich, spiced custard.

Raisins

Use 20% — about 80 g. Add before the soak so they plump in the custard as it sits. Soft, sweet, and completely at home with nutmeg.

Chopped Pecans

Use 12% — about 48 g. Sprinkle half through the cubes and half on top before baking. The top nuts toast while the pudding bakes and add real crunch.

Dark Chocolate Chunks

Use 15% — about 60 g. Fold through before the soak. The chunks melt into pockets that taste especially good against the sourdough tang.

Diced Apple

Use 20% — about 80 g, cut small. Add with the cubes before pouring the custard. The pieces soften in the bake and bring a fresh, juicy note.

Candied Ginger

Use 10% — about 40 g, finely chopped. Scatter before the soak. A little goes a long way: warm heat that lifts the cinnamon and nutmeg.

Orange Zest

Use about 4 g — the zest of one orange. Whisk it straight into the custard. It brightens the whole dish without changing its texture at all.

Each inclusion above changes the pudding in a different direction. Cranberries and orange zest push it bright, pecans and chocolate push it rich, and apple and ginger keep it fresh and warm at the same time.

Serve a plain batch first if you are new to the recipe. Once you know how the custard sets and how the tang sits, a single well-chosen inclusion is easy to judge — and easy to repeat.

Variations

  • Brioche swap: build the pudding with day-old sourdough discard challah cubes for a richer, softer center.
  • Toffee top: scatter the pecan variation over the top and finish each serving with a spoonful of warm caramel sauce.
  • Individual puddings: divide the soaked mixture between buttered ramekins and bake until just set for neat single servings.

What to Pair It With

This pudding is rich, warm, and sweet, so the best pairings either cut that richness or lean into it on purpose. Something cold and plain resets the palate between bites, while something warm and spiced makes the whole serving feel deeper and cozier. Pick one direction per serving and it always lands.

  • Whipped cream, barely sweetened, spooned over warm servings.
  • A warm eggnog drizzle — a few spoonfuls poured over each portion.
  • Strong coffee or black tea, which cut the richness cleanly.
  • Vanilla ice cream on a warm scoop for a hot-and-cold contrast.
  • Crisp bacon on the side when the pudding is served as a brunch bake.

Get the full recipe for Sourdough Discard Eggnog Bread Pudding.

Get Your Sourdough Starter →

Questions? Just message us — we'll get back to you, we promise. No AI chatbots here, just real people who bake sourdough every day.

Our 100% Activation Guarantee

Zero Risk. Zero Guesswork. Just Real Sourdough.

Bake or Get Covered: If your starter fails to activate into a bubbly, active, bake-ready culture.
We’ll either send you a fresh replacement batch completely free or issue a 100% refund.

No hoops to jump through, no complicated returns, and no hard feelings.