Homemade sourdough eggnog bread pudding in a speckled navy enamel dish on a scarred maple table

🍮 Sourdough Discard Eggnog Bread Pudding — Custardy, Warmly Spiced & Holiday-Cozy

🍮 Sourdough Discard Eggnog Bread Pudding

Custardy. Warmly spiced. The coziest way to use up bread AND discard.

Makes 8 Servings  •  Beginner Friendly  •  Discard-Powered  •  Ready in ~1 Hour 15 Minutes

If sourdough discard eggnog bread pudding sounds like three good ideas arguing in one dish, wait until you taste it. The gentle tang of sourdough cuts straight through rich, nutmeg-spiced eggnog custard, so every spoonful tastes festive instead of heavy.

This is the holiday bake that rescues everything: the end of a sourdough loaf going stale on the counter, the discard you were about to toss, and the last of the eggnog carton. Cube, whisk, soak, bake. That is genuinely the whole job.

🍮 Why You'll Love This Bread Pudding

  • ✔ Uses both leftover sourdough bread and a good scoop of discard
  • ✔ Custardy in the middle with golden, crisped bread tips on top
  • ✔ Warm nutmeg and cinnamon in every bite — pure holiday comfort
  • ✔ Assembles in about 15 minutes, then the oven does the work
  • ✔ Perfect make-ahead Christmas breakfast or dessert
  • ✔ Equally happy warm with sauce or cold straight from the fridge

🍮 Sourdough Discard Eggnog Bread Pudding

Bread Pudding

  • 400 g day-old sourdough bread, cut in 1-inch cubes (about 5 cups, loosely packed)
  • 480 g eggnog (about 2 cups)
  • 120 g sourdough discard (about ½ cup, unfed is perfect)
  • 150 g eggs (about 3 large eggs)
  • 100 g granulated sugar (about ½ cup)
  • 45 g melted butter (about 3 tbsp), plus more for the dish
  • 5 g vanilla extract (about 1 tsp)
  • 2 g ground nutmeg (about ½ tsp), plus more for dusting
  • 2 g ground cinnamon (about ½ tsp)
  • 3 g fine sea salt (about ½ tsp)

Optional, But Lovely

  • 75 g raisins or dried cranberries (about ½ cup)
  • Powdered sugar, whipped cream, or a warm eggnog drizzle for serving

🥣 Step 1: Cube and Dry the Bread

Cut your sourdough into rough 1-inch cubes — uneven is good, because the pointy corners crisp up beautifully. Spread them in a buttered 9×13-inch baking dish, or a deep 9-inch dish if you want taller servings.

If your bread is fresh and soft, dry the cubes in a 300°F (150°C) oven for about 10 minutes first. Dry bread drinks up custard; fresh bread just gets soggy.

Beginner Tip: Keep some crust on the cubes. Those crusty edges are the best bites in the whole dish.

🥚 Step 2: Whisk the Eggnog Custard

In a big bowl, whisk the eggs and sugar until pale and a little frothy, about 1 minute. Whisk in the eggnog, sourdough discard, melted butter, vanilla, nutmeg, cinnamon, and salt until completely smooth.

The discard disappears right into the custard — no lumps, no fuss. It simply adds a gentle tang underneath all that warm spice, the same way it does in our other discard bakes.

Beginner Tip: Taste the custard before it goes on the bread. Eggnogs vary in sweetness, so add a spoonful more sugar now if yours needs it.

⏳ Step 3: Soak — Do Not Rush This

Pour the custard evenly over the bread cubes. Press everything down gently with a spatula so the top cubes get their turn in the bath, then scatter over the raisins or cranberries if you are using them.

Let it soak for at least 30 minutes at room temperature. The cubes should look saturated and heavy, with almost no loose liquid sloshing in the dish.

Pro-Level Move: Cover and refrigerate the soaked dish overnight. Morning-you just preheats the oven and bakes — the easiest holiday breakfast move there is.

🔥 Step 4: Bake Until Just Set

Heat the oven to 350°F (175°C). Bake the pudding for 45–55 minutes, until the top is deep golden, the edges are puffed, and the center gives a slight, custardy jiggle when you nudge the dish.

A knife slipped into the center should come out mostly clean, with a little creamy custard clinging to it — not runny egg.

Beginner Tip: If the top browns too fast, lay a loose sheet of foil over it for the last 15 minutes. Golden is the goal; dark and bitter is not.

🍽️ Step 5: Rest, Dust, and Serve Warm

Rest the pudding for at least 15 minutes before scooping. The custard finishes setting as it stands, and the servings hold together instead of sliding apart.

Dust with a little extra nutmeg and powdered sugar, then serve warm with whipped cream or a spoonful of warmed eggnog poured over each serving.

THEN TAKE THE CORNER PIECE. Crisp top, custardy middle, all the spice. You baked it. You earned it.

👩🍳 Squirrelly Girl Baker's Tips

🍞 1. Stale bread is an ingredient, not a problem. Day-old (or older) sourdough is exactly right here. This recipe exists because good bread deserves a second act.

🥛 2. Full-fat eggnog wins. Rich eggnog makes a custard that sets silky instead of watery. Save the light stuff for drinking.

🌰 3. Fresh nutmeg changes everything. If you have a whole nutmeg and a grater, use it. The aroma is warmer and rounder than the pre-ground kind.

⏳ 4. The soak is the recipe. Under-soaked bread bakes up dry in the middle no matter how good your custard is. Give it the full 30 minutes.

🍒 5. Cranberries love eggnog. Dried cranberries add bright, tart pops that keep the rich custard from feeling one-note — very festive, too.

🧊 Make It Ahead

Assemble the whole dish, cover, and refrigerate for up to 24 hours before baking — the flavor actually improves. Bake straight from the fridge, adding about 5 extra minutes.

Leftover baked pudding keeps up to 4 days in the fridge in an airtight container. Freeze individual portions, well wrapped, for up to 2 months; thaw overnight in the fridge.

Reheat like this: covered in a 325°F (165°C) oven for 15–20 minutes, or a single portion in the microwave for about a minute. A splash of eggnog or milk before reheating brings back the just-baked softness.

🚨 Eggnog Bread Pudding Troubleshooting

My pudding is soggy on the bottom.

Your bread was too fresh, or the soak was so long the cubes fell apart. Dry fresh cubes briefly in the oven first, and keep the soak to the times above.

The center is still runny.

It needs more time. Return it to the oven in 5-minute bursts until the center only jiggles slightly — it finishes setting as it rests.

It tastes too tangy.

Your discard was likely quite ripe. Next time use fresher discard, or drop it to 60 g and add the same weight in extra eggnog.

The top got too dark.

Tent loosely with foil partway through, and check your oven rack — the middle rack keeps the sugary top from racing ahead.

Can I taste the eggnog enough?

If your eggnog is mild, bump the nutmeg up a pinch and finish servings with a warm eggnog drizzle. The spice is what reads as "eggnog" most.

⚠️ Baker's Warning

Making this pudding has a predictable side effect.

No sourdough loaf in your house will ever be allowed to go stale in peace again.

People will start "accidentally" leaving half a loaf out.

You're officially the bread pudding person.

🐿️ Ready to Bake Better Sourdough?

Great discard recipes start with a strong, active starter — and great bread pudding starts with a great loaf.

Squirrelly Girl's flaked dehydrated starter is easy to activate, beginner-friendly, and backed by our Activation Guarantee, so the loaves (and puddings) keep coming.

FREE Shipping in Canada, the US and the UK • Easy to Activate • 100% Activation Guarantee

Get Squirrelly Girl Sourdough Starter

Learn more about the Activation Guarantee — and if your starter ever sulks, our guides will talk you through it.

One starter. Endless sourdough possibilities.

❓ FAQ: Sourdough Discard Eggnog Bread Pudding

Can I use active starter instead of discard?

Yes. Active starter works exactly the same in the custard. Discard is the classic move here because the recipe was built to use it up, tang and all.

What bread works best for bread pudding?

Day-old sourdough with a sturdy crumb is ideal — it soaks up custard without collapsing. Avoid loaves with strong savory flavors like garlic or olive for this sweet version.

Can I make this without eggnog?

You can swap in the same weight of whole milk plus an extra egg yolk and a little more nutmeg, but honestly, the eggnog is the holiday heart of this one.

How do I know when bread pudding is done?

The edges are puffed and golden, the center jiggles just slightly, and a knife comes out mostly clean. It finishes setting during the 15-minute rest.

Is bread pudding breakfast or dessert?

Yes. Warm with whipped cream after dinner, or cold with coffee the next morning — holiday rules apply, and holiday rules are generous.

❤️ Happy Holiday Baking!

Cube the bread.

Whisk the custard.

Soak it properly.

And prepare for the kind of pudding that makes everyone ask, "You made this from leftovers?"

#sourdoughdiscard #eggnogbreadpudding #sourdoughrecipes #holidaybaking #breadpudding #christmasbaking

Back to blog

Our 100% Activation Guarantee

Zero Risk. Zero Guesswork. Just Real Sourdough.
Bake or Get Covered: If your starter fails to activate into a bubbly, active, bake-ready culture, we’ll either:Send you a fresh replacement batch completely free, or Issue a 100% full refund.

No hoops to jump through, no complicated returns, and no hard feelings.