Sourdough Discard Peppermint Chocolate Cookies — Flavors, Inclusions & Pairings

The Flavor Profile
Crust & crumb: Crisp, crackly edges around a thick, fudgy center. The chilled discard dough bakes up chewy rather than cakey, with melted chocolate running through every bite.
Flavor: Deep cocoa first, then a cool wave of peppermint, then crunchy candy cane on top. A gentle sourdough tang sits underneath and makes the chocolate taste darker.
Why it takes inclusions so well: The dough is thick and cold when it goes into the oven, so chips, chunks, and nuts stay suspended instead of sinking or melting away.
How Inclusions Fit This Recipe
This cookie dough is mixed, chilled, scooped, and topped — so inclusions have two natural entry points: folded in before the chill, or pressed on top before baking.
- Make the dough exactly as the recipe directs, with its chocolate chips folded in last.
- Fold any chunky swap-ins — white chocolate, nuts, or extra dark chunks — in at the same moment as the chips, before chilling.
- Chill the dough for at least 30 minutes so the inclusions stay put when scooped.
- Scoop 40 g balls and press delicate toppings — crushed candy cane, flaky salt — onto the tops right before baking.
- Bake 10–12 minutes at 350°F (175°C) and pull while the centers still look soft.
For extra inclusions beyond the recipe's chips, keep additions in the 10–30% of flour weight range — that is about 19–57 g for this recipe's 190 g of flour. Keep pieces pea-sized or smaller so the cookies hold together.
The Best Inclusions for This Loaf
White Chocolate Chips
Use 15% of flour weight, about 29 g, swapped in for part of the dark chips and folded in before chilling. White chocolate softens the cocoa edge and makes the peppermint taste creamier.
Dark Chocolate Chunks
Use 20% of flour weight, about 38 g, swapped in for part of the chips. Chunks melt into puddles instead of holding their shape, giving you fudgy pockets in every bite.
Crushed Candy Cane (Extra, Inside)
Use 10% of flour weight, about 19 g, folded in coarse — never as dust. Inside the dough it melts into peppermint streaks; save the prettiest pieces for the tops as the recipe directs.
Toasted Walnuts
Use 12% of flour weight, about 23 g, chopped small and folded in before chilling. Toast them first for 5 minutes so they stay crunchy against the soft, fudgy crumb.
Espresso Powder
Use 1% of flour weight, about 2 g (1 teaspoon), whisked in with the cocoa. You will not taste coffee — you will just taste more chocolate. It is the quiet upgrade nobody can name.
Flaky Sea Salt
Use about 1% of flour weight, roughly 2 g, sprinkled on top while the cookies are still warm from the oven. Salt sharpens both the chocolate and the mint, and the flakes add a tiny crunch.
Cocoa Nibs
Use 10% of flour weight, about 19 g, folded in before chilling. Nibs stay firm in the oven, so they give you a deep, slightly bitter crunch that stands up to the sweet candy cane and the soft center.
A note on balance: this dough already leans sweet from two sugars and the candy topping. Every inclusion above works because it either deepens the chocolate, sharpens the mint, or adds texture — nothing here is just more sugar. If you add two inclusions at once, keep the combined total inside the 19–57 g range so the dough still scoops cleanly, chills properly, and bakes up thick instead of spreading around loose pieces.
Peppermint strength is the other dial to watch. The extract lives in the dough, the candy cane lives on top, and the two hit at different moments — cool aroma first, crunch second. If you fold candy cane inside as well, you get a third layer in the middle of the bite. Build it one layer at a time and taste a test cookie before committing the whole batch.
Variations
- Double-mint: keep the extract at a full teaspoon and add the inside candy cane fold-in above for mint in every layer.
- Mocha peppermint: add the espresso powder and swap half the chips for dark chocolate chunks for a deeper, less sweet cookie.
- White chocolate peppermint: swap all the dark chips for white chocolate chips and keep the candy cane tops — sweeter, creamier, and very pretty on a tray.
What to Pair It With
- Hot cocoa: the classic — a warm mug against the cool peppermint crunch is the whole point.
- Coffee or espresso: bitterness balances the sweet candy cane top beautifully.
- Vanilla ice cream: sandwich a scoop between two cookies, or crumble one warm cookie over a bowl.
- A cookie tray: set them beside plain shortbread and snickerdoodles — the dark color and red-white tops make everything else look good too.
- Cold milk: still undefeated with a fudgy chocolate cookie, warm from the oven.
Get the full recipe — every amount, step, and troubleshooting fix is there.
Questions? Just message us — we'll get back to you, we promise. No AI chatbots here, just real people who bake sourdough every day.
Our 100% Activation Guarantee
Zero Risk. Zero Guesswork. Just Real Sourdough.
Bake or Get Covered: If your starter fails to activate into a bubbly, active, bake-ready culture.
We’ll either send you a fresh replacement batch completely free or issue a 100% refund.
No hoops to jump through, no complicated returns, and no hard feelings.