How to Get a Sourdough Starter: Every Way, Honestly Compared
You have decided you want a sourdough starter. Wonderful — but where do you actually get one? There are four honest ways, and each has real pros and cons. Here they are, compared fairly, so you can pick the one that fits your kitchen and your patience.
1. From a friend or fellow baker
Pros: Free, instant, and proven — you know it raises their bread. A starter from a friend also comes with a built-in advice line.
Cons: You inherit an unknown history. Ask what flour it is used to and what feeding rhythm it keeps, because a sudden change can sulk for a few days. And if none of your friends bake, this door is closed.
2. From a local bakery
Pros: Some bakeries will sell or share a piece of their starter, and a bakery culture is worked hard every day.
Cons: Availability is hit and miss, and the feeding history varies — a piece taken from a commercial rhythm has to adjust to your home schedule and flour. Worth asking; just do not count on it.
3. Make your own from flour and water
Pros: The cheapest route, and deeply satisfying when it works — it is yours from day one.
Cons: It takes a week or two of daily feeding before it can raise bread, it commonly stalls around the middle when it looks dead (it usually is not), and some attempts do fail. If you choose this road, follow our step-by-step guide to making a starter from scratch.
4. Buy dehydrated starter flakes
Pros: Flakes arrive by mail and wait patiently in the cupboard — shelf-stable until the day you are ready. You start with an established, mature culture instead of a newborn one, with a step-by-step activation guide, and you are typically baking within days.
Cons: It costs money, and you still do the waking-up feeds yourself — there is no way around feeding a starter, whichever way you get it.
Our honest take
If you have a baking friend, ask them — that is a lovely way to start. If you enjoy a project, make your own. But if you want the shortest, surest path to a first loaf, start with a culture that is already mature. Squirrelly Girl starter flakes are the same starter we have fed and baked with for about 15 years — begun by a friend about 20 years before that — made in Canada, with a guide in every packet and our 100% Activation Guarantee. There is also a gluten-free sourdough starter built from scratch on brown rice flour, and a Starter Duo with one of each.
Get Your Sourdough Starter Flakes
⭐ 4.9 stars from 748 reviews — read what bakers say about their first loaves.
Free shipping, no surprises
Every starter ships free — free shipping in Canada, the US and the UK. Your starter travels as light, shelf-stable flakes, ready to wake up whenever you are.
However you get it, then bake
Once your starter is bubbling, put it to work with our free Recipe Library — 150+ sourdough recipes, from a simple first loaf to discard pancakes, pizza and cinnamon rolls.
Quick questions
What is the fastest way to get a sourdough starter?
A spoonful from a friend is instant. Next fastest is dehydrated flakes from an established culture — a few days of waking-up feeds and you are baking.
Is a bought starter better than a homemade one?
Neither is magically better — what matters is maturity and consistent feeding. A bought culture from a mature starter simply skips the fragile first weeks.
What if my starter does not activate?
Every Squirrelly Girl order is covered by our 100% Activation Guarantee. If it does not wake up, we make it right.
Questions before you order? See our frequently asked questions.
Our 100% Activation Guarantee
Zero Risk. Zero Guesswork. Just Real Sourdough.
Bake or Get Covered: If your starter fails to activate into a bubbly, active, bake-ready culture.
We’ll either send you a fresh replacement batch completely free or issue a 100% refund.
No hoops to jump through, no complicated returns, and no hard feelings.