Bake Sourdough Both Ways: Wheat and Gluten-Free

Bake Sourdough Both Ways: Wheat and Gluten-Free

Two plates of buttered toast, one from a wheat sourdough loaf and one from a gluten-free loaf, with jam

There are two kinds of sourdough mornings: the one with a crackling wheat boule, open crumb ready for butter — and the one with a soft gluten-free tin loaf, sliced thick for toast. Most bakers have to pick a lane. With two starters on the counter, you do not: you bake sourdough both ways, and each loaf gets the culture it actually needs.

The Starter Duo is the two-lane setup in one order. Our wheat sourdough starter — fed and baked with by us for about 15 years, begun by a friend roughly 20 years before that — handles the classic bakes. The gluten-free sourdough starter, a separate culture raised from scratch on brown rice flour, handles the rest. Both ship as dehydrated flakes and wake up in days.

Get the Duo and Bake Both Ways →

What changes between the two

The wheat routine is the familiar one from our activation guide: feed, watch for the double, shape, bake in a Dutch oven. The gluten-free routine, from the gluten-free activation guide, is its own craft: a batter-style dough, a healthy peak at half to three-quarters risen, a lined tin, and a crumb that stays fine and tender. The flavours differ too — bold and tangy against mild and gently sweet — which is precisely why baking both never gets boring. Toast, sandwiches, soup-dunking: each loaf finds its jobs.

One order, both lanes open

Both starters are covered by our Activation Guarantee — if one does not activate, we replace it or refund you — and the Duo ships free in Canada, the US and the UK. Keep the cultures in separate, labelled containers, feed them on the same days, and your kitchen runs both ways without doubling your effort.

Get Both Starters — Your Table, Both Ways →

Two starters, two crumb shots, one very versatile baker.

Bakers who run both ways also waste less. The wheat starter's discard folds into crackers and pancakes; the gluten-free culture's extra batter becomes flatbreads and wraps for the gluten-free eaters at the table. Two cultures, two little ecosystems, and a kitchen where almost nothing fermented ever goes to waste — that is the quiet economics of the Duo.

Baking both ways — questions

Do the two starters get fed the same way?

The rhythm is the same — regular small feedings — but the flour differs. The wheat starter eats wheat flour; the gluten-free starter eats brown rice flour and must never be fed wheat. Label the containers and the routine becomes second nature.

Which loaf is better for sandwiches?

Honestly, both. The wheat boule makes a hearty, chewy sandwich; the gluten-free tin loaf slices evenly and toasts beautifully. Most both-ways bakers end up rotating by mood rather than by rules.

Can one dough ever substitute for the other?

No — and that is exactly why the Duo exists. A wheat culture cannot make a gluten-free loaf, and the rice culture was never meant to imitate a boule. Each starter does its own job properly.

Questions? Just message us — we'll get back to you, we promise. No AI chatbots here, just real people who bake sourdough every day.

Our 100% Activation Guarantee

Zero Risk. Zero Guesswork. Just Real Sourdough.

Bake or Get Covered: If your starter fails to activate into a bubbly, active, bake-ready culture.
We’ll either send you a fresh replacement batch completely free or issue a 100% refund.

No hoops to jump through, no complicated returns, and no hard feelings.